Article body

INTRODUCTION

Three-dimensional geological information is vital to conceptually develop sophisticated metallogenic models for granitoid massifs (e.g., Cuney et al. 1985 1992; Arniaud et al. 1984). Conventional models based on near-surface data remain largely speculative. The Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources initiated a deep-drilling program to study the compositional variability with depth of the granitoid rocks of the South Mountain batholith (SMB), the largest peraluminous granitoid body in the Appalachian orogen, which contains important mineralization of tin and uranium. Associated with this known mineralizationare extensive alteration zones, the surface or near-surface expressions of which have been the targets of mineral exploration in recent years. The drill core provides an insight into deep-seated hydrothermal activity in the SMB and yield important data for petrological and metallogenic studies of peraluminous granites in Paleozoic foldbelts on a worldwide basis. The deep-drilling project also yielded information on the use of the granites as a depository of radioactive waste material and as a potential source of geothermal energy.

The purpose of this paper is to document the petrographic and geochemical characteristics of the core from the drill hole near Digby in southwestern Nova Scotia (Fig.1). The drill penetrated to a depth of about 1.5 km and is the deepest on-shore hole in the Canadian Appalachian orogen. The site of the drill hole was selected close to the periphery of the massif in order to intersect the least differentiated granitic rocks of the batholith. The results indicate hydrothermal activity deep within the SMB and potential mineralization, although there is no obvious expression of this at the surface.

Figure 1

Fig. 1 Generalized geological map of southwestern Nova Scotia (modified from MacDonald et al. 1992 and Clarke et al. 1997) showing the South Mountain batholith and the locations of the drill hole (DDH), East Kemptville tin (EK) and Millet Brook uranium (MB) deposits, the Scrag Lake pluton (SLP) and the town of Digby (D). Insert map shows the location of the study area.

-> See the list of figures

GEOLOGICAL SETTING

The SMB, which intrudes Cambro-Ordovician turbiditic rocks of the Meguma Group and overlying Siluro-Devonian (Emsian) White Rock and Torbrook formations composed of volcano-sedimentary sequences, crops out over an area of about 7,300 km2. The granitoid rocks of the SMB range from megacrystic biotite granodiorite (with up to 20% biotite) to equigranular leucogranite containing less than 2% biotite. All the granitoid rocks of the SMB are peraluminous, as expressed by the presence of corundum in the normative mineralogy and by the local occur-rence of primary muscovite, cordierite, andalusite, garnet, and topaz. Mapping (Ham et al. 1990; Horne et al. 1991; MacDonald et al. 1992) has shown that the SMB is composed of several distinct plutons. Intrusive relationships among these bodies were established during field mapping and various geochronological studies based upon Ar/Ar, Rb/Sr, U/Pb and Pb/Pb indicate that the plutons intruded within a narrow time interval of less than 5 Ma at about 370 Ma ago (Reynolds et al. 1981, 1987; Kontak and Chatterjee 1992; Keppie and Dallmeyer 1994). The host sedimentary rocks of the Meguma Group and overlying formations were subjected to regional metamorphism ranging from lower green-schist to middle amphibolite facies during the Acadian orogeny, which has been dated at ~400 Ma (Reynolds et al. 1987; Hicks et al. 1999). The SMB was emplaced well after the peak of meta-morphism and is unconformably overlain by sedimentary rocks of Namurian to Tournaisian age (Howie and Barss 1975). The batholith was emplaced at a depth equivalent to a pressure of about 4 kb and was uplifted and unroofed within about 10 Ma (Clarke and Chatterjee 1988; Clarke et al. 1997). This short duration suggests that the unroofing was probably due to the final stages of collision between the Meguma and Avalon terranes.

The SMB hosts two important hydrothermal deposits: a large U (+ Cu-Ag) deposit at Millet Brook (Chatterjee and Strong 1984) in the northeastern part of the batholith and the East Kemptville tin deposit (Kontak 1994; Halter et al. 1996) located in southwestern Nova Scotia (Fig.1). The fracture-related vein-type U deposit of Millet Brook is hosted by biotite granodiorite (the least differentiated rock-type of SMB), whereas the tin deposit is enclosed in highly evolved topaz leucogranite (Dostal and Chatterjee 1995, 2000). Mineralization in both deposits is accompanied by alteration of the host granitoid rocks. The U mineralization is associated with intense hydrothermal alteration, whereas massive quartz-topaz-cassiterite greisenization accompanies the tin mineralization. The age of the hydrothermal events and attending mineralization in both deposits is around 370 Ma (Kontak and Chatterjee 1992; Keppie et al. 1993) and could be of great significance in terms of the metallogenic evolution of the SMB.

DRILL HOLE

The drill hole, located at Wallace Lake near Digby (44°29'08.5", 65°43'19.7", Fig.1), penetrated the northwestern portion of the Scrag Lake pluton. The pluton covers an area of 2,460 km2 and is composed of biotite granodiorite and biotite monzogranite in the proportion of 1:4. The biotite monzogranite is a medium to coarse grained rock (grain size 0.1 to > 0.5 cm) with megacrystic to seriate texture composed of perthitic K-feldspar, zoned plagioclase, quartz, and biotite (10—17%). Muscovite and ilmenite occur in accessory amounts. Compared to monzogranite, biotite granodiorite has higher proportion of plagioclase relative to K-feldspar and higher contents of biotite (up to 20%). In both rock types, biotite contains inclusions of apatite, zircon, monazite, and titanite.

Petrographic and airborne radiometric data show that the Scrag Lake pluton is zoned and the most primitive granitoid rocks occur in the northwestern part of the body (Horne et al. 1991), where the hole was drilled. The drill core was systematically documented; it contains four distinct zones with contrasting degrees of fracturing and associated alteration (Fig. 2). This division is also supported by borehole geophysical data: magnetic susceptibility, natural gamma-ray radiometry and induced-polarization (P. Kileen, personal communication, 1992).

PETROGRAPHY

The drill hole intersected texturally uniform megacrystic biotite granodiorite (according to the classification of Streckeisen 1976) with xenoliths of cleaved country rocks and others of unknown affinities. The four zones (Fig. 2) defined by petrographic and hand-specimen observations are (A) unaltered granodiorite which forms the drill core from 0 to 290 m, (B) weakly altered granodiorite from 290 m to 550 m, (C) altered and brecciated granodiorite from 550 to 1,100 m with mineralized fractures, and (D) alternating bands of unaltered and altered granodiorite from 1,100 to the bottom at a depth of about 1,450 m (Fig. 2). Fractures associated with the altered rocks are 0.5 mm to 2.5 cm wide. Some are mineralized and contain aggregates of galena, sphalerite, pyrrhotite, chalcopyrite, pyrite, hematite, quartz, and carbonate minerals, with minor amounts of U-phosphate and fluorite. Others are mostly filled by quartz, carbonate minerals, chlorite, kaolinite, and hematite. Adjacent to the fractures, the host rocks are strongly chloritized. Fracture-related alteration extends for a distance of up to 2 m from the fractures although generally the distance is significantly less. There are typically 8 to 10 fractures per 1 m of drill core of the altered granodiorite and about 20% of this zone is intensely altered. In the weakly altered zone, about 5—10% of the rocks are altered. The xenoliths are present only in the upper part of the hole, in the unaltered granodiorite zone, and even in this zone, their abundance decreases with depth.

All fresh biotite granodiorite is composed primarily of quartz, plagioclase, K-feldspar, and biotite. Additionally, the rocks contain accessory garnet, apatite, zircon, monazite, and ilmenite. The composition of the plagioclase ranges from An37 in the core to An17 in the rim. Subordinate K-feldspar is typically perthitic. Biotite (~15—20 vol.%) with Mg values (Mg/Mg+Fe+Mn) around 0.35, normally forms large euhedral crystals (up to several mm in size) with prominent inclusions of apatite, monazite, and zircon.

Altered granodiorite typically contains hematite, quartz, carbonate minerals, chlorite, sericite, albite, and K-feldspar. The other associated hydrothermal minerals are epidote, titanite, chlorite, muscovite, tourmaline, and minor amounts of opaque minerals such as sphalerite, chalcopyrite, uraninite, and autunite. The most characteristic feature of the altered rocks is brittle deformation and pervasive degradation of plagioclase and biotite. Four distinct alteration types are recognized: albitization, potassic alteration, carbonatization, and silicification. These types typically occur together and form a continuum. The intensity of alteration increases towards the fracture zones.

Albitization is characterized by the presence of albite (An0—5), which occurs as thin continuous rims on plagioclase, as euhedral grains with quartz, and sparsely as small blebs with secondary biotite. In rare cases, albite forms veins up to 2 cm thick. Minor amounts of titanite are generally associated with albitized rocks.

Figure 2

Fig. 2 The drill hole profile showing the distribution of fractures and alteration zones.

-> See the list of figures

Figure 3

Fig. 3 Compositional variations in the drill core with the depth. Dashed vertical lines represent the averages of granodiorite of the South Mountain batholith (MacDonald et al. 1992; Chatterjee and Muecke, 1982).

-> See the list of figures

Potassic alteration generates secondary K-feldspar (microcline), muscovite/sericite, and biotite. These minerals occur as discrete grains or are associated with primary minerals. The most distinct morphological feature is the replacement of plagioclase by secondary K-feldspar. Muscovite/sericite forms small flakes in the above association. Secondary biotite is devoid of inclusions and reaches up to 10% of volume. Epidote and carbonate minerals are also commonly produced during this alteration.

Carbonatization is defined by calcite, which occurs as veins and discrete grains (interstitial or associated with albite) or, together with chlorite and epidote, forms a matrix in strongly brecciated rocks. Carbonate minerals are normally accompanied by hematite.

Silicification is manifested by secondary quartz, which replaces plagioclase, K-feldspar, and biotite or occurs as thin stringers. In open spaces, secondary quartz forms euhedral crystals.

Rocks from depths of 290—550 m, the weakly altered zone, show only early stages of alteration and the primary magmatic mineral assemblage is dominant. Comparable weakly altered rocks also occur at a depth >1,100 m, although fresh and altered rocks are the predominant rock types of this zone.

SAMPLING AND ANALYTICAL METHODS

A total of 95 samples were taken from the drill core at approximately 15 m intervals (Fig. 3). Each sample represents a length of 15—20 cm of core. Major elements and the trace elements Rb, Ba, Sr, Zr, Nb, Y, Ga, Cr, Ni, V, Cu and Zn were analyzed by X-ray fluorescence methods at the Regional Geochemical Centre at Saint Mary's University. Precision is generally better than 5% for the major oxides and between 5 to 10% for trace elements (Dostal et al. 1986). The concentrations of Th and U were determined by instrumental neutron activation and delayed neutron activation techniques, respectively, at Atomic Energy Commission of Canada, Ottawa. Rare-earth elements (REE) and Hf were determined in fourteen samples by inductively-coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) using Na2O2 sinter fusion at Memorial University of Newfoundland. Precision is between 2 and 4% and Longerich et al. (1990) reported the details of the ICP-MS analyticalprocedure.

GEOCHEMISTRY

Fresh granodiorite

According to normative composition recast in terms of quartz (Q), alkali feldspar (A) and plagioclase (P) (LeMaitre 1989), most fresh rocks of the drill hole are of granodiorite composition and the rest straddle the boundary between the monzogranite and granodiorite fields (Fig. 4). Some altered samples plot into the monzogranite field towards the A apex (Fig. 4). Fresh rocks are peraluminous (i.e. molecular Al2O3/(CaO+K2O+Na2O) >1) with SiO2 ranging from 65 to 68 wt.% and with K/Rb ratios ranging from 190 to 250. Compared to the granodiorite samples of the Scrag Lake pluton collected on the surface (Ham et al. 1990), the rocks from the drill core have slightly lower contents of Th but higher CaO, MgO, Sr, Ba and Zr (Table 1). Relative to the average of SMB biotite granodiorite given by MacDonald et al (1992), they are less evolved, and have lower contents of SiO2 (Fig. 5). The chondrite-normalized REE patterns of the drill core granodiorite samples are enriched in light REE with (La/Yb)n ~ 8 to 11 and typically show a small but distinct negative Eu anomaly (Fig. 6). The patterns are similar to those of granodiorite from elsewhere in SMB (Muecke and Clarke 1981).

The fresh granodiorite samples define distinct variation trends for some major and trace elements where plotted against SiO2 (Fig.5) or other differentiation indices, suggesting that the rocks underwent fractional crystallization. Large variation of Sr accompanied by relatively constant Rb/Sr (not shown) and Mg/Rb ratios with increasing SiO2 (Fig. 5) suggest fractionation mainly of plagioclase and biotite.

Mass balance calculations using major element data (Bryan et al. 1969) show that the fresh sample with the lowest SiO2 content (sample 39; Table 2) taken to represent the most primitive and most likely parent magma can produce the sample of the zone A with the highest SiO2 (sample 27) by fractional crystallization of plagioclase and biotite in the proportion of 2.3:1. The calculations using the composition of the crystal core of both of these minerals imply a separation of 18.3% of this assemblage. The observed concentrations of Rb, Sr, and Ba are in good agreement with the calculated abundances obtained from an equilibrium fractional crystallization equation, implying that their distribution is controlled predominantly by fractional crystallization. This calculation confirms that a closed-system fractional crystallization model can explain most of the evolution of the granodiorite units. MacDonald and Clarke (1991) suggested that the fractional crystallization in SMB was achieved by gravitational and flowage separation of crystals and liquids.

Figure 4

Fig. 4 Quartz-alkali feldspar-plagioclase (QAP) plot for normative composition of the rocks of the drill hole. Fields (after Le Maitre 1989): SGR, syenogranite; MZG, monzogranite; QMZ, monzonite; GRD, granodiorite; TO, tonalite. Fresh rocks are shown as circles. The dashed line shows the field of the altered rocks.

-> See the list of figures

Table 1

Table 1. Average chemical compostion (±1i for grandiorites from the South Mountain of Barthodith

Table 1. Average chemical compostion (±1i for grandiorites from the South Mountain of Barthodith

-> See the list of tables

Figure 5

Fig. 5 (Above) Variations of CaO (wt.%), MgO (wt.%), Sr (ppm) and MgO (wt.%)/100xRb (ppm) with respect to SiO2 (wt .%) for the rocks of the drill hole. Altered rocks shown as crosses. The diamond indicates the average granodiorite of the South Mountain batholith of MacDonald et al. (1992). The dashed line outlines the field of the fresh rocks.

-> See the list of figures

Figure 6

Fig. 6 (Left) Chondrite-normalized REE patterns of the rocks of the drill hole. Normalizing values after Sun (1992). (a) Fresh granodiorites including the average granodiorite of the South Mountain batholith (SMB; MacDonald et al. 1992). (b) Altered granodiorites.

-> See the list of figures

Table 2

Table 2. Major and trace element compositions of representative rocks from the drill hole.

Table 2. Major and trace element compositions of representative rocks from the drill hole.

-> See the list of tables

Altered Granodiorite

The averages of the weakly and strongly altered zones as well as the altered rocks from the lowermost zone are similar to those of the fresh rocks from the drill core (Table 1). The alteration of the granodiorite leads to a larger variation of concentrations of most elements as also shown by larger standard deviations in the altered rocks compared to the fresh rocks (Table 1). Only a few altered samples show compositional characteristics distinctly different from the fresh rocks. Moderate to weak brittle deformation, accompanied by potassic alteration and/or albitization, caused a decrease of Ca, and an increase of K and Ba (Table 2). Silicification, characterized by numerous stringers of quartz, mainly resulted in a dilution effect without noticeable chemical changes of trace elements (samples 274 and 280, Table 2). Both these processes did not noticeably modify the REE and high-field-strength elements (HFSE). Intense shearing, leading to extreme granulation (sample 139, Table 2), produced a pronounced increase of K, Rb, Ba, Zr, and Y accompanied by the fractionation of ratios involving even HFSE such as Zr/Y and Zr/Nb.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

The rocks in the drill core do not show a pronounced primary vertical zonation (Fig. 3) although the abundances of some elements and the element ratios, particularly Th/U, in the alteration zones show a larger scatter than in the fresh rocks. The fresh rocks from the lower part of the drill core have chemical compositions close to those from the top part, indicating that the granodioritic magma was fairly homogeneous. This limited primary compositional variation can be mostly explained by closed-system fractional crystallization of plagioclase and biotite.

The strongly sheared samples (such as sample 139, Table 2) have geochemical characteristics comparable to the mineralized zones containing chalcopyrite, pyrite, sphalerite, and autunite from the Millet Brook deposit (Chatterjee and Strong 1984), although the alteration intensity and elemental enrichment are much less pronounced in the drill core samples (Table 1). The similarity of chemical signatures generated by the mineralization and intense alteration in the Millet Brook deposit and the strongly altered samples from the drill core suggests that the alteration may be related to the same hydrothermal process. The altered zone encountered in the drill hole may represent channelways for the migration of mineralizing hydrothermal fluids or represent the deeper-seated roots of a shallow deposit/mineralization.

The association of alteration with fractures in both the drill core and in other areas throughout the SMB implies that the alteration is due to fluid flow along the fractures. In the Millet Brook deposit, Chatterjee and Strong (1985) inferred from oxygen isotopic data that the alteration is caused by fluids formed during fractionation of granitic magma. This interpretation is supported by dating of the Millet Brook deposit (~370 Ma; Kontak and Chatterjee 1992; Keppie et al. 1993), which indicates that magmatism, alteration, and mineralization are approximately coeval. It suggests that the alteration of the rocks in the drill core was mainly produced by fluids derived during the cooling of the batholith. Minerals of the wall-rocks and fracture fillings imply that the fluids were oxidizing and at low temperature.

Most of the chemical variation in the altered rocks of the drill core can be correlated with the observed mineralogical changes. Albitization and sericitization of plagioclase led to the mobilization of Ca whereas elevated concentrations of K and Ba seem to be related to the newly formed hydrothermal K-feldspar. Degradation of biotite probably resulted in mobilization of Ti, Y, and Zr, whereas the higher concentrations of U appear to be due to the presence of minute amounts of U-phosphate. The average compositions of the three zones as well as the compositions of most samples are similar, implying only limited mobility of elements.

If similar alteration zones are widespread elsewhere in the batholith, this study indicates that the potential for hidden economic mineral deposits is much greater than suggested by surface features. Therefore, our results may have significant implications for exploration in the SMB and other peraluminous granitic bodies. The association of mineralization, as seen in the drill core and also Millet Brook deposit, with the most primitive rocks of the batholith further documents that economic mineral deposits in granitoid rocks are not always hosted by the most evolved and fractionated rocks, although these later phases may play an important role in their genesis as documented for the Millet Brook uranium mineralization. Chatterjee and Strong (1984) concluded that the uranium mineralization is hosted by the least differentiated biotite granodiorite but is genetically associated to monzogranite and leucogranite.

Our research also suggests that due to intensity and extent of fracturing within the SMB, the batholith is not a suitable candidate for the storage of the radioactive waste material. However, high temperatures measured in the drill hole (~68°C at a depth of about 1,450 m) implies that the granite has promise as a source of geothermal energy.