Abstracts
Abstract
‘Argument’ has multiple meanings and referents in contemporary argumentation theory. Theorists are well aware of this but often fail to acknowledge it in their theories. In what follows, I distinguish several senses of ‘argument’ and argue that some highly visible theories are largely correct about some senses of the term but not others. In doing so, I hope to show that apparent theoretical rivals are better seen as collaborators or partners, rather than rivals, in the multi-disciplinary effort to understand ‘argument,’ arguments, and argumentation in all their varieties. I argue as well for a pluralistic approach to argument evaluation and argumentative norms, since arguments and argumentation can be legitimately evaluated along several dimensions, but urge that epistemic norms enjoy conceptual priority.
Keywords:
- argument,
- arguments,
- argumentation,
- epistemic theory,
- pragma-dialectical theory,
- rhetorical theory,
- virtue argumentation theory
Résumé
« Argument » a de multiples significations et référents dans la théorie contemporaine de l’argumentation. Les théoriciens en sont bien conscients mais oublient souvent de le reconnaître dans leurs théories. Dans ce qui suit, je distingue plusieurs sens du terme « argument » et je soutiens que certaines théories très visibles sont largement correctes dans certains sens du terme mais pas dans d’autres. Ce faisant, j’espère montrer que les théoriciens apparemment rivaux sont mieux perçus comme des collaborateurs ou des partenaires, plutôt que comme des rivaux, dans l’effort multidisciplinaire visant à comprendre « argument », les arguments et l’argumentation dans toutes leurs variétés. Je soutiens également une approche pluraliste de l’évaluation des arguments et des normes argumentatives, puisque les arguments et l’argumentation peuvent être légitimement évalués selon plusieurs dimensions, mais je conseille vivement que les normes épistémiques bénéficient d’une priorité conceptuelle.
Download the article in PDF to read it. Download
Appendices
Bibliography
- Aberdein, Andrew. 2010. Virtue in argument. Argumentation 24(2): 165-179.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Aberdein, Andrew. 2014. In defence of virtue: The legitimacy of agent-based argu-ment appraisal. Informal Logic 34(1): 77-93.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Aberdein, Andrew. 2018a. Inference and virtue. In Argumentation and inference: Proceedings of the 2nd European conference on argumentation, Fribourg 2017, vol. 2, eds. S. Oswald and D. Maillat, 1-9. London: College Publications.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Aberdein, Andrew. 2018b. Commentary on Gascón, “Virtuous arguers: Responsible and reliable.” In Argumentation and inference: Proceedings of the 2nd European conference on argumentation, Fribourg 2017, vol. 1, eds. S. Oswald and D. Maillat, 123-128. London: College Publications.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Aberdein, Andrew. 2023. The fallacy fallacy: From the Owl of Minerva to the Lark of Arete. Argumentation 37(2): 269–280.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Aberdein, Andrew and Daniel H. Cohen. 2016. Introduction: Virtues and arguments. Topoi 35(2): 339-343.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Aikin, Scott F. 2008. Three objections to the epistemic theory of argument rebutted. Argumentation and Advocacy 44(3): 130-142.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Bailin, Sharon. 1999. The trouble with Percy. Informal Logic 19(2-3): 161-170.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Bailin, Sharon and Mark E. Battersby. 2016. Reason in the balance, 2e. Indianapolis: Hackett.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Bailin, Sharon. 2022. ‘Inoculating students against conspiracy theories: The case of Covid-19.’ In The pandemic of argumentation, Argumentation Library, vol. 43, eds. S. Oswald, M. Lewiński, S. Greco, and S. Villata, 271-289. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Battersby, Mark E. 1989. Critical thinking as applied epistemology: Relocating critical thinking in the philosophical landscape. Informal Logic 11(2): 91-100.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Battersby, Mark E. 2016. Enhancing rationality: Heuristics, biases, and the critical thinking project. Informal Logic 36(2): 99-120.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Biro, John and Harvey Siegel. 1992. Normativity, argumentation, and an epistemic theory of fallacies.’ In Argumentation illuminated: Se-lected papers from the 1990 international conference on argumentation, eds. F. H. van Eemeren, Charles A. Willard, Rob Grootendorst, and J. Anthony Blair, 85-103. Dordrecht: Foris.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Biro, John and Harvey Siegel. 2006a. In defense of the objective epistemic approach to argumentation.’ Informal Logic 25(3): 91-101.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Biro, John and Harvey Siegel. 2006b. Pragma-dialectic versus epistemic theories of arguing and arguments: Rivals or partners?’ In Considering pragma-dialectics: A festshrift for Frans H. van Eemeren on the occasion of his 60th birthday, eds. P. Houtlosser and A. van Rees, 1-10. Mahuah, NJ: Erl-baum.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Biro, John and Harvey Siegel. 2015. Argument and context. Cogency 7(2): 27-41.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Blair, J. Anthony. 2004. Argument and its uses. Informal Logic 24(2): 137-151.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Blair, J. Anthony. 2012. Groundwork in the theory of argumentation: Selected papers of J. Anthony Blair. Argumentation Library vol 21. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Blair, J. Anthony and Ralph H. Johnson. 1993. Dissent in fallacyland, part 1: Problems with van Eemeren and Grootendorst.’ In Argument and the postmodern challenge: Proceedings of the eighth SCA/AFA Conference on argumentation, ed. R. E. McKerrow, 188-190. Annandale VA: Speech Communication Association.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Bondy, Patrick. 2015. Virtues, evidence, and ad hominem arguments. Informal Logic 35(4): 450-466.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Bondy, Patrick. 2018. Epistemic rationality and epistemic normativity. NY: Routledge.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Bondy, Patrick. 2021. ‘The epistemic norm of inference and non-epistemic rea-sons for belief. Synthese 198(2): 1761-1781.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Botting, David. 2010. A pragma-dialectical default on the question of truth. Informal Logic 30(4): 413-434.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Bowell, Tracy and Justine Kingsbury. 2013. Virtue and argument: Taking character into account. Informal Logic 33(1): 22-32.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Cohen, Daniel H. 2013. Virtue, in context. Informal Logic 33(4): 471-485.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Cohen, Daniel H. 2022. You can’t judge an argument by its closure. Informal Logic 42(4): 669-684.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Dutilh Novaes, Catarina. 2021a. Argument and argumentation. The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Fall 2021 Edition), ed. Edward N. Zalta (ed.). URL accessed 5 February 2022: <https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2021/entries/argument/>.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Dutilh Novaes, Catarina. 2021b. The dialogical roots of deduction: Historical, cognitive, and philosophical perspectives on reasoning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Eemeren, Frans H. van 2012. The pragma-dialectical theory under discussion. Argumentation 26(4): 439-457.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Eemeren, Frans H. van and Rob Grootendorst. 2004. A systematic theory of argumentation: The pragma-dialectical approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Eemeren, Frans H. van and Peter Houtlosser. 2003. The development of the pragma-dialectical approach to argumentation. Argumentation 17(4): 387-403.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Feldman, Richard. 1994. Good arguments. In Socializing epistemology: The social dimensions of knowledge, ed. F. F. Schmitt, 159-188. NY: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Feldman, Richard. 2005a. Deep disagreement, rational resolutions, and critical thinking. Informal Logic 25(1): 13-23.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Feldman, Richard. 2005b. Useful advice and good arguments. Informal Logic 25(3): 277-287.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Fisher, Walter R. 1987. Human Communication as narration: Toward a philosophy of reason, value, and action. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Freeman, James. 2005. Acceptable premises: An epistemic approach to an informal logic problem. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Garssen, Bart and Jan Albert van Laar. 2010. A pragma-dialectical response to objectivist epistemic challenges. Informal Logic 30(2): 122-141.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gascón, José Ángel. 2016. Virtue and arguers. Topoi 35(2): 441-450.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gascón, José Ángel. 2017. Brothers in arms: Virtue and pragma-dialectics. Argumentation 31(4): 705-724.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gascón, José Ángel. 2018. Virtuous arguers: Responsible and reliable. Argumentation 32(2): 155-173.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gilbert, Michael A. 1994. Multi-modal argumentation. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 24(2): 159-177.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gilbert, Michael A. 1995. Arguments & arguers. Teaching Philosophy 18(2): 125-138.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gilbert, Michael A. 1997. Coalescent argumentation. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gilbert, Michael A. 2007. Natural normativity: Argumentation theory as an engaged discipline. Informal Logic 27(2): 149-161.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Gilbert, Michael A. 2011. The kisceral: Reason and intuition in argumentation. Argumentation 25(2): 163-170.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Godden, David. 2015. Argumentation, rationality, and psychology of reasoning. Informal Logic 35(2): 135-166.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Godden, David. 2016. On the priority of agent-based argumentative norms. Topoi 35(2): 345-357.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Godden, David. 2017. On the norms of visual argument: A case for normative non-revisionism. Argumentation 31(2): 395-431.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goddu, G. C. 2011. Is ‘argument’ subject to the product/process ambiguity? Informal Logic 31(2): 75-88.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goddu, G. C. 2015. Towards a foundation for argumentation theory. In Reflections on theoretical issues in argumentation theory, Argumentation Library 28, eds. F. H. van Eemeren and B. Garssen, 43-51. Dordrecht: Springer.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goddu, G. C. 2016. What (the hell) Is virtue argumentation? In Argumentation and reasoned action: Proceedings of the 1st European conference on argumentation, Lisbon, 2015, Vol. II, eds. D. Mohammed and M. Lewiński, 439-448. London: College Publications.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goldman, Alvin I. 1994. Argumentation and social epistemology. Journal of Philosophy 91(1): 27-49.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goldman, Alvin I. 1997. Argumentation and interpersonal justification. Argumentation 11(2): 155-164.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goldman, Alvin I. 1999. Knowledge in a social world. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goldman, Alvin I. 2003. An epistemological approach to argumentation. Informal Logic 23(1): 51-63.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Goody, Jack. 2006. The theft of history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Groarke, Leo. 2015. Going multimodal: What is a mode of arguing and why does it matter? Argumentation 29(2): 133-155.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Groarke, Leo. 2019. Matching schemes of argument: Verbal, visual, multimod-al. In Proceedings of the ninth conference of the international society for the study of argumentation, eds., Bart Garssen, David Godden, Gordon R. Mitchell, and Jean H. M. Wagemans, 443-457. Amsterdam: Sic Sat.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Groarke, Leo. 2021. Informal logic. The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Fall 2021 Edition), ed., Edward N. Zalta. URL accessed 18 May 2022: <https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2021/entries/logic-informal/>.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Johnson, Ralph H. 2000. Manifest rationality: A pragmatic theory of argument. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Kišiček, Gabrijela. 2018. Can we translate sounds into words? Informal Logic 38(3): 346-361.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Lloyd, Geoffrey E. R. 2018. The ambivalences of rationality: Ancient and modern cross-cultural explorations. Cambridge: Cambridge Uni-versity Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Lumer, Christoph. 1988. The disputation – a special type of cooperative argumentative dialogue.’ Argumentation 2(4): 441-464.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Lumer, Christoph. 1991. Structure and function of argumentations – An epistemological approach to determining criteria for the validity and adequacy of argumentations. In Proceedings of the second international conference on argumentation, vol. 1A, eds. F. H. van Eemeren, R. Grootendorst, J. A. Blair, and C. Willard, 98-107. Amsterdam, SICSAT.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Lumer, Christoph. 2005a. Introduction: The epistemological approach to argumentation – A map. Informal Logic 25(3): 189-212.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Lumer, Christoph. 2005b. The epistemological theory of argument: How and why?’ Informal Logic 25(3): 213-243.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Lumer, Christoph. 2012. The epistemic inferiority of pragma-dialectics – A reply to Botting. Informal Logic 32(1): 51-82.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- O’Keefe, Daniel. 1977. Two concepts of argument. The Journal of the American Forensic Association 13:121-128.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Paglieri, Fabio. 2015. Bogency and goodacies: On argument quality in virtue argumentation theory. Informal Logic 35(1): 65-87.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Pinto, Robert C. 2001. Argument, inference and dialectic: Collected papers on informal logic. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Popa, Eugen Octav 2016. Criticism without fundamental principles. Informal Logic 36(2): 192-216.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Reed, Christopher A., and T. J. Norman. 2004. Argumentation machines: New frontiers in argument and computation. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Scheffler, Israel. 1989. Reason and teaching. Indianapolis: Hackett. First published 1973.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 1988. Educating reason: Rationality, critical thinking, and education. London: Routledge.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 1997. Rationality redeemed?: Further dialogues on an educational ideal. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 1998. Knowledge, truth and education. In Education, knowledge, and truth: Beyond the postmodern impasse, ed. D. Carr, 19-36. London: Routledge.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 1999a. Argument quality and cultural difference. Argumentation 13(2): 183-201.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 1999b. Multiculturalism and the possibility of Transcultural educational and philosophical ideals. Philosophy 74: 387-409.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 2001. ‘Incommensurability, rationality and relativism: In science, culture and science education. In Incommensurability and related matters, eds. P. Hoyningen-Huene and H. Sankey, 207-224. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 2004. Relativism. In Handbook of epistemology, eds. I. Niiniluoto, M. Sintonen, and J. Woleński, 747-780. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 2007. Multiculturalism and rationality. Theory and research in education 5(2): 203-223.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 2013. Argumentation and the epistemology of disagreement. Cogency 5(1): 135-170.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 2017. Education’s epistemology: Rationality, diversity and critical thinking. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey. 2018. Justice and justification. Theory and Research in Education 16(3): 308-329.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey and John Biro. 1997. Epistemic normativity, argumentation, and fallacies. Argumentation 11(3): 277-292.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey and John Biro. 2008. Rationality, reasonableness, and critical rationalism: Problems with the pragma-dialectical view. Argumentation 22(2): 191-203.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey and John Biro. 2010. The pragma-dialectician’s dilemma: Reply to Garssen and van Laar. Informal Logic 30(4): 457-480.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Siegel, Harvey and John Biro. 2021. Walton on argument, arguments, and argumentation. Journal of Applied Logics 8(1): 183-194.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Tindale, Christopher W. 1999. Acts of arguing: A rhetorical model of argument. Albany: SUNY Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Tindale, Christopher W. 2004. Rhetorical argumentation: Principles of theory and practice. Los Angeles: Sage.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Tindale, Christopher W. 2014. Global governance, argumentation, and diversity. In Argu-ing global governance: Agency, lifeworld, and shared reasoning, eds. C. Bjola and M. Kornprobst, 141-156. London: Routledge.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Tindale, Christopher W. 2021. The anthropology of argument: Cultural foundations of rhetoric and reason. NY: Routledge.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Walton, Douglas. 1990. What Is reasoning? What is an argument? Journal of Philosophy 87(8): 399-419.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Walton, Douglas. Reed, Christopher and Fabrizio Macagno. 2008. Argumentation schemes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Willard, Charles A. 1983. Argumentation and the social grounds of knowledge. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
- Žagar, Igor. 2021. Four critical essays on argumentation. Ljubljana: Pedagoški Inštitut.Google Scholar Search this bibliographic reference on Google Scholar
