Article body

Abigail Krasner Balbale’s The Wolf King: Ibn Mardanīsh and the Construction of Power in al-Andalus, is a major achievement. It sheds new light on the dynamic borderland context of twelfth-century Iberia, a world of shifting political frontiers, cultural and intellectual efflorescence, overlapping spheres of culture and authority, and the intersection between various networks of exchange. The “Wolf King,” the figure who is focus of the study, has been known by several names across the various linguistic and cultural traditions of medieval Iberia: Rex Lupus in Latin, El Rey Lobo in Spanish, and Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muḥammad b. Saʿd b. Mardanīsh in Arabic. The Wolf King constitutes the first comprehensive English-language study about Ibn Mardanīsh (d. 1172), while also critically assessing the historiographical construction of his legend from the Middle Ages to the present. Drawing upon methodologies from history, Islamic studies, and art history, and a rich array of sources — chronicles, chancery documents, poetry, coinage, architecture and portable objects — Balbale examines Ibn Mardanīsh’s articulation of royal sovereignty, religious identity and political legitimacy. The Wolf King provides insights into the complex career and legacies of a local ruler whose alliances encompassed an array of political actors ranging from Iberian Christian kings, Genoese and Pisan merchants, and Andalusi nobles; a leader of an independent principality who recognized the sovereign authority of both a Christian king in Castile and an Abbasid caliph in Baghdad (minting coins in the name of the latter); a master strategist and frontier warrior renowned for transforming Murcia into a cultural and intellectual centre; and the founder of a dynasty whose marriage alliances and family strategy was so elaborate that his maternal grandson would eventually rise to the position of Almohad caliph, leader of an empire that had once seen Ibn Mardanīsh as its “single, most formidable enemy.” 1 The Wolf King situates Ibn Mardanīsh within complex networks of affiliation and resistance extending from Castile and North Africa to Baghdad, emphasizing his connections with both Latin Christendom and the broader Islamic world.

The book, working across multiple languages, genres, and fields, successfully challenges the still often prevalent paradigm of al-Andalus as a peripheral or exceptional place, while illustrating the various ways in which it was more closely integrated with its Christian neighbours and with the Islamic East than is typically understood. There are many significant historical, historiographical, and methodological achievements here, but I would like to highlight one in particular. A significant accomplishment of the book is its brilliant usage of material culture as well as textual sources for reconceptualizing Andalusi history during the twelfth century. Doing so constitutes a major methodological intervention in the ways that it employs epigraphic, iconographic, and numismatic evidence alongside (and sometimes against) written sources to reconstruct and reevaluate the political ideology of Ibn Mardanīsh, which is particularly evident in chapters 3–5. These chapters incorporate both textual evidence and material culture to successfully complicate the conventional representation of Ibn Mardanīsh by providing insights into his ambitious cultural and political program, which included the patronage of intellectuals and religious scholarship; the recognition of the Abbasid caliphate; the deployment of a specific set of aesthetic, artistic and architectural motifs; intricate diplomacy with Latin Christendom; and the instrumentalization of Arab Muslim lineage to legitimize his reign both within the region and among his contemporaries in the broader Mediterranean world.

Throughout the book, Balbale successfully demonstrates her central claim that “objects, architecture, and archaeology can expose, through their materials, forms and techniques, and movement, the aspirations and affiliations of those who produced or collected them and, in the process, highlight the routes of people, goods and ideas.” 2 The Wolf King illustrates the ways that employing a vast array of textual, visual and material evidence can provide new historical insights and “reveal connections that might subvert the [medieval] chronicles’ ideological aims.” 3 The book provides an important model for comparative Mediterranean history, with Balbale drawing heavily upon her expertise in Islamicate art and iconography to situate Ibn Mardanīsh within a rich history that extends from the late antique Near East, the early medieval Umayyad and Fatimid contexts, to his contemporaries in Norman Sicily, the Almohad Caliphate and Castile during the twelfth century.

Through an examination of the specific ways in which the surviving material culture reflected Ibn Mardanīsh’s political ideology, Balbale illustrates the ways in which his cultural program “constituted a visual genealogy, legible to varying degrees to those who visited his court, that connected the ruler to local forebears, distant leaders, and political and religious ideologies.” 4 The Wolf King invites scholars to carefully consider the value of material evidence — coinage, iconography, inscriptions — for an examination of Andalusi political culture during the Middle Ages.

Coinage is an immensely valuable window into the articulation of royal power in al-Andalus. This medium constituted a distinct idiom of power and authority, and enables scholars to better understand continuities, as well as ruptures, between — and sometimes within — various dynasties and political regimes. The value of coinage becomes even more apparent once it is situated within a larger body of textual and material evidence, as Balbale’s book demonstrates in the case of Ibn Mardanīsh. This figure existed in a continuum. He inherited (and transformed) a set of traditions, while also playing a key role in the formation of new foundations in the fashioning of political legitimation. There are other important examples of Andalusi frontier lords whose coinage provides key insights into their own political trajectories and aspirations. The two that I have worked on most closely are Sayf al-Dawlah ibn Hūd (d. 1146), Ibn Mardanīsh’s predecessor as regional ruler of Murcia between 1144 and 1146, and Muḥammad ibn Naṣr (r. 1232–1273), the founder of the Nasrid kingdom of Granada. Each of these figures was enmeshed in similar strategies of legitimation: the fashioning of elaborate Arab Muslim genealogies, extensive alliances with Muslims and Christians alike, diplomacy across the Mediterranean, and the patronage of particular forms of scholarship, art, and architecture. They have also both suffered their fair share of misrepresentation that has sought to fit them into a particular binary of “frontier warrior” or “treacherous vassal” that has shaped the understanding of too many Andalusi figures in medieval Iberia.

The Wolf King is an original piece of scholarship that is thoroughly researched and beautifully written. It will be useful for historians and art historians, medievalists and Islamicists alike, seeking to think critically about the articulation of kingship in the Islamic world, the historiographical legacies of al-Andalus, and the manner in which borderland dynamics and political legitimation were deeply intertwined in medieval Iberia. The Wolf King is an important work of interdisciplinary and comparative history that employs an array of textual, visual, and material evidence to reincorporate al-Andalus into the broader world of the medieval Mediterranean. There are very few studies that are capable of weaving together various threads and histories into such a rich tapestry with such erudition.