Book ReviewsRecensions de publication

Under-Served: Health Determinants of Indigenous, Inner-City, and Migrant Populations in Canada. Akshaya Neil Arya, A. N., & Thomas Piggott (Editors). Canadian Scholars, 2018, 424 pages

  • Patrick Cloos

…plus d’informations

  • Patrick Cloos, MD, MSc, PhD
    Professeur, École de travail social, Département de médecine sociale et préventive, École de santé publique, Centre de recherche en santé publique (CRESP), Université de Montréal

L’accès à cet article est réservé aux abonnés. Seuls les 600 premiers mots du texte seront affichés.

Options d’accès :

  • via un accès institutionnel. Si vous êtes membre de l’une des 1200 bibliothèques abonnées ou partenaires d’Érudit (bibliothèques universitaires et collégiales, bibliothèques publiques, centres de recherche, etc.), vous pouvez vous connecter au portail de ressources numériques de votre bibliothèque. Si votre institution n’est pas abonnée, vous pouvez lui faire part de votre intérêt pour Érudit et cette revue en cliquant sur le bouton “Options d’accès”.

  • via un accès individuel. Certaines revues proposent un abonnement individuel numérique. Connectez-vous si vous possédez déjà un abonnement, ou cliquez sur le bouton “Options d’accès” pour obtenir plus d’informations sur l’abonnement individuel.

Dans le cadre de l’engagement d’Érudit en faveur du libre accès, seuls les derniers numéros de cette revue sont sous restriction. L’ensemble des numéros antérieurs est consultable librement sur la plateforme.

Options d’accès
Couverture de Volume 39, numéro 1, 2022, p. 5-185, Canadian Social Work Review / Revue canadienne de service social

This book is definitely aimed at a medical and public health audience for whom there is a need to broaden training to include an awareness of how political, social, and cultural contexts affect health practices and both individual and population health. The book repeats what is already known in public health: health and health inequities are the result of living and working conditions, the health system, and behavioural and individual factors. For example, health results from access to resources and opportunities, including but not limited to healthcare services. From a theoretical perspective, Dennis Raphael (Chapter 2, pp. 23–38) also recalls the need to focus on the causes of the causes: life circumstances are themselves shaped by political ideologies, social organization, and economic policies. It is these elements that are categorized as social structure, within which Raphael (and other authors) does not forget to include two other types of historical state powers — colonialism and racism. Raphael does not, however, fully explain how these powers and their deleterious consequences have evolved over time, or how their entanglement with capitalist ideology and liberal economies produces social inequalities. Among chapters of special interests, Hanna Gros’s, on mental health in prisons (Chapter 18, pp. 246–252), is especially welcome, because this area of research and practice is often overlooked, even in social work. Gros raises important issues such as human rights, isolation, and family issues. Lesley Cooper et al. (Chapter 24, pp. 327–340) remind us of the importance of taking into account one’s own cultural values, social position, and power in the care relationship with marginalized populations, such as Indigenous Peoples. Thus, the authors discuss the necessity for students and health professionals to reflect on various issues related to power and systems of privilege (e.g., White and male privilege), values and perspectives, and oppressive behaviours that can impact the care relationship. It seems obvious that these contextual elements plus principles of social justice and equity are already, and hopefully, part of social work education. The question here is: to what extent are these elements systematically and universally taken into account in social work education and practice? In Chapter 25 (pp. 341–351), Ryan Meili and Thomas Piggott remind us that, often, the dominant discourse about health is limited to healthcare, medicine, technology, and biomedical- and hospital-centred logic. Indeed, it is this approach that the Canadian political system — both federal and provincial — advocates, as we saw during the COVID-19 pandemic. Meili and Piggott remind us that health services play only a minor role in terms of public health. In this, health professionals need to understand that it is social factors (e.g., income, education) that determine behaviour and ultimately health. Thus, the determinants of health are structural, and the political system should be changed, think Meili and Piggott (p. 348). So the observation is made and consists of repeating what we have known for a long time, but that is too often set aside: the structural level is the main source of inequalities. The authors focus on making the care relationship fairer and more equitable, which is already a relevant step. This book is therefore important for several reasons. One of them is to make some marginalized social categories of the population more visible. It shows that ideological factors shape the role that the state plays in relation to who can access what. Ideology therefore shapes the redistribution of and access to wealth. The fundamental question is: at what level should action be taken to reduce social inequalities in health? Answering this question should consider the historical links between public health, medicine, and the state — …