Résumés
Résumé
Les récents développements du conflit israélo-palestinien semblent apporter la preuve – s'il en fallait encore une – que ce conflit n'est pas tant compréhensible en termes politiques que psychologiques. En effectuant une synthèse de la littérature scientifique psychologique portant spécifiquement sur ce conflit, nous espérons établir la pertinence d'une telle approche pour le politiste et, peutêtre, pour le responsable politique. À la suite d'une introduction revenant sur les intérêts d'une telle analyse, nous considérons trois éclairages psychologiques sur le conflit israélo-palestinien: les perceptions du conflit par ses acteurs, les dynamiques identitaires et l'émergence de l'agressivité, et enfin les effets de la violence sur la santé mentale. Une conclusion résume ces apports et ouvre le débat.
Mots-clés :
- conflit israélo-palestinien,
- psychologie,
- violence,
- revue de littérature
Abstract
The latest episodes of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict bring further evidence that this conflict cannot be understood solely in political terms. In this paper, we review a significant set of psychological scientific articles that specifically examine this conflict, and we argue that such psychological insights may renew perspectives towards its understanding and, perhaps, resolution. After having set the issue in our introduction, we proceed in three steps, which correspond to the three kinds of insights that we argue could be gained from psychology. First, we consider the perceptions of the conflict by its actors. Second, we consider the dynamics of identity and aggressive behaviour. Third, we consider the effects of violence on mental health. Eventually, a conclusion sums up these insights and opens up the debate.
Keywords:
- Israeli-Palestinian conflict,
- psychology,
- violence,
- literature review
Parties annexes
Bibliographie
- Aboud France E. et Maria Amato, 2003, « Development and Socialization Influences on Intergroup Bias », dans R. Brown et S. Gaertner, Intergroup Processes, Londres, Blackwell : 63-85.
- Afana Abdel-hamid et Timraz Neda, 2003, « The Assessment of Mental Disorders in Primary Health Care Clinics in the Gaza Strip », Primary Health Care Research and Development, vol. 4, no 3 : 267-274.
- Afana Abdel-hamid, Samir Qouta et Eyad El Sarraj, 2004, « Mental Health Needs in Palestine », Humanitarian Exchange Magazine, no 28.
- Afifi Rima et al., 2010, « Quaderoon Youth Mental Health Promotion Programme in the Burj El Barajneh Palestinian Refugee Camp, Beirut, Lebanon. A Community-intervention Analysis », The Lancet Series, juillet.
- Batniji Rajaie et al., 2009, « Health as Human Security in the Occupied Palestinian Territory », The Lancet, vol. 373, no 9669 : 1133-1143.
- Bar-On Daniel, 2002, « Le silence des psychologues. Pourquoi n’existe-t-il pas une psychologie israélienne “post-sioniste” ? », Revue internationale de psychosociologie, vol. 8, no 2 : 45-66.
- Bar-Tal Daniel, 1988, « Political Psychology in Israel », Political Psychology, vol. 9, no 4 : 737-742.
- Bar-Tal Daniel, 2001, « Why Does Fear Override Hope in Societies Engulfed by Intractable Conflict, as It Does in the Israeli Society ? », Political Psychology, vol. 22, no 3 : 601-627.
- Bar-Tal Daniel et Dikla Antebi, 1992, « Siege Mentality in Israel », International Journal of Intercultural Relations, no 16 : 251-275.
- Bar-Tal Daniel et Dan Jacobson, 1998, « A Psychological Perspective on Security », Applied Psychology. An International Review, vol. 47, no 1 : 59-71.
- Beit-Hallahmi Benjamin, 1972, « Some Psychosocial and Cultural Factors in the Arab-Israeli Conflict. A Review of the Literature », The Journal of Conflict Resolution, vol. 16, no 2 : 269-280.
- Bilu Yoram, 1989, « The Other as a Nightmare. The Israeli-Arab Encounter as Reflected in Children’s Dreams in Israel and the West Bank », Political Psychology, vol. 10, no 3 : 365-389.
- Canetti-Nisim Daphna, Gal Ariely et Eran Halperin, 2008, « Life, Pocketbook, or Culture. The Role of Perceived Security Threats in Promoting Exclusionist Political Attitudes toward Minorities in Israel », Political Research Quarterly, vol. 61, no 1 : 90-103.
- Elbedour Salman, David T. Bastien et Bruce A. Center, 1997, « Identity Formation in the Shadow of Conflict. Projective Drawings by Palestinian and Israeli Arabs from the West Bank and Gaza », Journal of Peace Research, vol. 34, no 2 : 217-231.
- Elmusa Sharif S., 1993, « Dividing the Common Palestinian-Israeli Waters. An International Water Law Approach », Journal of Palestine Studies, vol. 22, no 3 : 57-77.
- Giacaman Rita, Neil Arya et Derek Summerfield, 2005, « Establishing a Mental Health System in the Occupied Palestinian Territories », Bulletin of the Board of International Affairs of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, no 9 : 16-18.
- Goldgeier James et Philip Tetlock, 2001, « Psychology and International Relations Theory », Annual Review of Political Science, vol. 4 : 67-92.
- Hamama-Raz Yaira, Zahava Solomon, Assaf Cohen et Avital Laufer, 2008, « ptsd Symptoms, Forgiveness, and Revenge among Israeli Palestinian and Jewish Adolescents », Journal of Traumatic Stress, vol. 21, no 6 : 521-529.
- Hammack Phillip L., 2006, « Identity, Conflict and Coexistence. Life Stories of Israeli and Palestinian Adolescents », Journal of Adolescent Research, vol. 21, no 4 : 222-247.
- Holsti Ole R., 1989, « The Political Psychology of International Politics. More than a Luxury », Political Psychology, vol. 10, no 3 : 495-500.
- Horton Richard, 2009, « The Occupied Palestinian Territory. Peace, Justice, and Health », The Lancet, vol. 373, no 9669 : 784-788.
- Jervis Robert, 1989, « Political Psychology. Some Challenges and Opportunities », Political Psychology, vol. 10, no 3 : 481-493.
- JervisRobert, 2004, « The Drunkard’s Search », dans S. Yiengar et W. McGuire (dir.), Explorations in Political Psychology, Durham, Duke University Press : 338-360.
- Kaitz Marsha et al., 2009, « The Intergenerational Effects of Trauma from Terror. A Real Possibility », Infant Mental Health Journal, vol. 30, no 2 : 158-179.
- Kaplowitz Noel, 1976, « Psychopolitical Dimensions of the Middle East Conflict. Policy Implications », The Journal of Conflict Resolution, vol. 20, no 2 : 279-318.
- Kaplowitz Noel, 1990, « National Self-Images, Perception of Enemies, and Conflict Strategies. Psychopolitical Dimensions of International Relations », Political Psychology, vol. 11, no 1 : 39-82.
- Kelman Herbert, 1987, « The Political Psychology of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. How Can We Overcome the Barrier to a Negotiated Solution ? », Political Psychology, vol. 8, no 3 : 347-363.
- Locke John, 1999, Traité du gouvernement civil, Paris, Flammarion.
- Massad Salva et al., 2009, « Mental Health of Children in Palestinian Kindergartens. Resilience and Vulnerability », Child and Adolescent Mental Health, vol. 14, no 2 : 89-96.
- Moore Dahlia et Salem Aweiss, 2002, « Hatred of “Others” among Jewish, Arab, and Palestinian Students in Israel », Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, vol. 2, no 1 : 151-172.
- Pappé Ilan, 2003, History of Modern Palestine. One Land, Two Peoples, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
- Pat-Horenczyk Ruth et al., 2009, « Posttraumatic Symptoms, Functional Impairment, and Coping among Adolescents on Both Sides of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. A Cross-Cultural Approach », Applied Psychology, vol. 58, no 4 : 688-708.
- Peres Yochanan, 1971, « Ethnic Relations in Israel », The American Journal of Sociology, vol. 76, no 6 : 1021-1047.
- Romani Vincent, 2005, « Quelques réflexions à propos des processus coercitifs dans les Territoires occupés », Études rurales, vol. 1 no 173 : 251-272.
- Rothman Jay et Marie Olson, 2001, « From Interests to Identities. Towards a New Emphasis in Interactive Conflict Resolution », Journal of Peace Research, vol. 38, no 3 : 289-305.
- Rouhana Nadim N. et Daniel Bar-Tal, 1998, « Psychological Dynamics of Intracable Ethnonational Conflicts. The Israeli-Palestinian Case », American Psychologist, vol. 53, no 7 : 761-770.
- Rouhana Nadim N. et Susan T. Fiske, 1995, « Perception of Power, Threat, and Conflict Intensity in Asymmetric Intergroup Conflict. Arab and Jewish Citizens of Israel », The Journal of Conflict Resolution, vol. 39, no 1 : 49-81.
- Sagi-Schwartz Abraham et al., 2004, « Les survivants de l’Holocauste et leurs enfants », Devenir, vol. 16, no 2 : 77-107.
- Schafer Mark, 1999, « Cooperative and Conflictual Policy Preferences. The Effect of Identity, Security, and Image of the Other », Political Psychology, vol. 20, no 4 : 829-844.
- Shalit Erel, 1994, « The Relationship between Aggression and Fear of Annihilation in Israel », Political Psychology, vol. 15, no 3 : 415-434.
- Shamir Michal et Tammy Sagiv-Schifter, 2006, « Conflict, Identity, and Tolerance. Israel in the Al-Aqsa Intifada », Political Psychology, vol. 27, no 4 : 569-595.
- Sharvit Keren et al., 2010, « Ideological Orientation and Social Context as Moderators of the Effect of Terrorism. The Case of Israeli-Jewish Public Opinion Regarding Peace », European Journal of Social Psychology, no 40 : 105-121.
- Slone Michelle, 2003, « The Nazareth Riots. Arab and Jewish Israeli Adolescents Pay a Different Psychological Price for Participation », The Journal of Conflict Resolution, vol. 47, no 6 : 817-836.
- Smith Charles D., 2010, Palestine and the Arab-Israeli Conflict. A History with Documents, Londres, Palgrave.
- Stein Janice, 2002, « Psychological Explanations of International Conflict », dans W. Carlsnaes, T. Risse et B. Simmons, Handbook of International Relations, Londres, Sage.
- Turner John et Katherine Reynolds, 2003, « The Social Identity Perspective in Intergroup Relations. Theories, Themes, and Controversies », dans R. Brown et S. Gaertner, Intergroup Processes, Londres, Blackwell : 133-152.
- Victoroff Jeff, 2005, « The Mind of the Terrorist. A Review and Critique of Psychological Approaches », The Journal of Conflict Resolution, vol. 49, no 1 : 3-42.
- Wedgwood Ruth, 2005, « The icj Advisory Opinion on the Israeli Security Fence and the Limits of Self-defence », American Journal of International Law, vol. 99, no 1 : 52-61.
- Weiss Meira, 2001, « The Body of the Nation. Terrorism and the Embodiment of Nationalism in Contemporary Israel », Anthropological Quarterly, vol. 75, no 1 : 37-62.