Abstracts
Abstract
“Liber de wazalkora” is the title of an unpublished Latin treatise on the construction and use of the planispheric astrolabe, which appears to have been compiled in southeast Germany (Bavaria) in the second half of the 12th century. It is to a large extent derived from other astrolabe sources available in the Latin West before 1100, but also contains material that has no precedent in any of the known literature. The analysis presented in this article concentrates on the Liber de wazalkora’s section on the use of the astrolabe, which is unusual for both its extraordinary length and frequently atypical astronomical content. A study of the Arabic loan vocabulary in this section leads to the conclusion that some parts of the text were derived from an unidentified Arabic source, presumably via a Latin intermediary.
Keywords:
- Astrolabe,
- Latin astronomy,
- 12th century,
- Arabic-to-Latin translations
Download the article in PDF to read it.
Download
Appendices
Biographical note
C. Philipp E. Nothaft is a £50-fellow at All Souls College, Oxford. He has published widely on the history of astronomy in the Middle Ages, including the recent monograph Graeco-Arabic Astronomy for Twelfth-Century Latin Readers (Leiden: Brill, 2023).
Bibliography
- Abraham Ibn Ezra. Genera astrolabiorum duo sunt…. See Millás Vallicrosa 1940.
- Ad intimas summe philosophie disciplinas…. See Millás Vallicrosa 1931, 271–275.
- Adelard of Bath. Libellus de opere astrolapsus. See Dickey 1982, 147–229.
- Arialdus. Cum inter omnia instrumentorum genera…. See MS Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, lat. 16652, ff. 28r–37v.
- Artis cuiuslibet consummatio. See Victor 1979, 108–471.
- Ascelinus of Augsburg. Compositio astrolabii. See Burnett 1998, 345–351.
- Astrologie speculationis exercitium…. See Millás Vallicrosa 1942, 316–321.
- Bede. De temporum ratione. See Jones 1977.
- Calcidius. In Timaeum. See Magee 2016.
- Computus Gerlandi. See Lohr 2013.
- De altitudine solis. See Millás Vallicrosa 1931, 292.
- De divisione igitur climatum…. See Millás Vallicrosa 1931, 320–322.
- De utilitatibus astrolabii. See Bubnov 1899, 114–147.
- Ezich Elkaurezmi. trans. Adelard of Bath. See Suter 1914.
- Hermann of Reichenau. De mensura astrolabii. See Drecker 1931.
- Honorius Augustodunensis. De animae exilio et patria. See Migne 1854, 1241–1246.
- Hyginus. De astronomia. See Viré 1992.
- Ibn al-Ṣaffār. Kitāb fī-l-‘amal bi-l-asṭurlāb. See Millás Vallicrosa 1955, 47–76 (Arabic section).
- Ibn al-Ṣaffār. Kitāb fī-l-‘amal bi-l-asṭurlāb, trans. John of Seville. See Millás Vallicrosa 1942, 261–284.
- Ibn al-Ṣaffār. Kitāb fī-l-‘amal bi-l-asṭurlāb, trans. Plato of Tivoli. See Lorch, Brey, Kirschner, and Schöner 1994.
- Inventis in sphaera rotunda coluris…. See Migne 1862, 940D–942B.
- John of Seville. Dixit Iohannes: Cum volueris facere astrolabium…. See Millás Vallicrosa 1942, 322–327.
- Macrobius. Commentarii in somnium Scipionis. See Willis 1970.
- Martianus Capella. De nuptiis Philologiae et Mercurii. See Willis 1983.
- Pliny. Naturalis historia. See Rackham 1949.
- Primum observandum est in spera…. See Cantor 1875, 224–225; Schonhardt 2022, 329–331.
- Pseudo-Bede. De mundi caelestis terrestrisque constitutione liber. See Pradel-Baquerre, Biasi, and Gévaudan 2016.
- Pseudo-Bede. Libellus de astrolabio. See Herwagen 1563, 467–470; Migne 1862, 955D–960A.
- Pseudo-Hermes. De sex rerum principiis. See Lucentini and Delp 2006.
- Pseudo-Māshā’allāh. De compositione astrolabii. See Thomson 2022.
- Pseudo-Māshā’allāh. Practica astrolabii. See Thomson 2022.
- Raymond of Marseilles. Liber cursuum planetarum. See d’Alverny, Burnett, and Poulle 2009, 126–341.
- Raymond of Marseilles. Tractatus astrolabii. See d’Alverny, Burnett, and Poulle 2009, 47–111.
- Regule de quarta parte astrolabii. See Millás Vallicrosa 1931, 305–307.
- Robert of Chester. Liber de officio astrolabii. MS Oxford, Bodleian Library, Canon. misc. 61, ff. 12r–22v.
- Rudolf of Bruges. Cum celestium sperarum diversam positionem…. See Lorch 1999.
- Sententie astrolabii. See Millás Vallicrosa 1931, 275–288.
- Spera fiat omni parte equalis et rotunda…. See MS London, British Library, Royal 13.A.XI, ff. 118v–119v.
- Speram celi facturus ducas circulum…. See Cantor 1875, 226–227; Dekker 2013, 202–203.
- Sumpto astrolapsu in meridie…. See Millás Vallicrosa 1931, 308.
- Vitruvius. De architectura. See Granger 1934.
- Bergmann, W. 1980. “Der Traktat ‘De mensura astrolabii’ des Hermann von Reichenau”. Francia 8: 65–103.
- Bergmann, W. 1985. Innovationen im Quadrivium des 10. und 11. Jahrhunderts. Stuttgart.
- Blume, D.; M. Haffner; and W. Metzger. 2012. Sternbilder des Mittelalters. vol. 1. Berlin.
- Borrelli, A. 2008. Aspects of the Astrolabe. Stuttgart.
- Borst, A. 1989. Astrolab und Klosterreform an der Jahrtausendwende. Heidelberg.
- Bubnov, N. 1899. Gerberti postea Silvestri II papae opera mathematica (972–1003). Berlin. Repr. Hildesheim 1963.
- Burnett, C. 1998. “King Ptolemy and Alchandreus the Philosopher: The Earliest Texts on the Astrolabe and Arabic Astrology at Fleury, Micy and Chartres”. Annals of Science 55: 329–368; with addendum ibid. 2000. 57: 187. Repr. in ch. 1 in C. Burnett. 2009. Arabic into Latin in the Middle Ages. Farnham.
- Burnett, C. 2022. “The Statements of Medieval Latin Translators on Why and How They Translate Works on Science and Philosophy from Arabic”. Pp. 445–487 in D. Gutas ed. Why Translate Science? Leiden.
- Caiazzo, I. 2002. Lectures médiévales de Macrobe. Paris.
- Caiazzo, I. 2012. “Sur l’astrolabe et le comput au XIIe siècle: nouveaux textes inédits”. Sudhoffs Archiv 96: 28–38.
- Caiazzo, I. and C. Burnett. 2011. “New Manuscripts of On the Astrolabe by Raymond of Marseilles”. Scriptorium 65: 338–349.
- Cantor, M. 1875. Die römischen Agrimensoren und ihre Stellung in der Geschichte der Feldmesskunst. Leipzig.
- Chabás, J. and B. R. Goldstein. 2012. A Survey of European Astronomical Tables in the Late Middle Ages. Leiden.
- Chlench, K. 2007. Johannes von Gmunden deutsch. Vienna.
- Comes, M. 1992–1994. “The ‘Meridian of Water’ in the Tables of Geographical Coordinates of al-Andalus and North Africa”. Journal for the History of Arabic Science 10: 41–51. Repr. 2014, ch. 12 in M. Rius Piniés and S. Gómez Muns edd. Homenaje a Mercè Comes. Barcelona.
- d’Alverny, M.-T. 1967. “Astrologues et théologiens au XIIe siècle”. Pp. 31–50 in A. Duval ed. Mélanges offerts à M.-D. Chenu, maître en théologie. Paris. Reprinted as ch. 16 in M.-T. d’Alverny. 1994. La transmission des textes philosophiques et scientifiques au Moyen Âge. Hampshire.
- d’Alverny, M.-T.; C. Burnett; and E. Poulle. 2009. Raymond de Marseille. Opera omnia. vol. 1. Paris.
- Dekker, E. 2013. Illustrating the Phaenomena. Oxford.
- Dickey, B. G. 1982. Adelard of Bath: An Examination Based on heretofore Unexamined Manuscripts. PhD dissertation, University of Toronto.
- Drecker, J. 1931. “Hermannus Contractus: Über das Astrolab”. Isis 16: 200–219.
- Freudenhammer, T. 2020. “Lupitus of Barcelona: On the Identity of a Tenth Century Scientific Translator”. Sudhoffs Archiv 104: 139–151.
- Gautier Dalché, P. 2013. “Le ‘tuyau’ de Gerbert, ou la légende savante de l’astronomie: origines, thèmes, échos contemporains (avec un appendice critique)”. Micrologus 21: 243–276.
- Granger, F. 1934. Vitruvius: On Architecture. vol. 2. Cambridge, MA.
- Hauke, H. 1982. “Die ehemals St. Petrischen Handschriften in der Bayerischen Staatsbibliothek”. Studien und Mitteilungen zur Geschichte des Benediktinerordens und seiner Zweige 93.1–2: 802–829.
- Hedenus, M. 2015. “Zur Deutung der Sphaera des Wilhelm von Hirsau”. Verhandlungen des Historischen Vereins für Oberpfalz und Regensburg 155: 9–18.
- Herwagen, J. 1563. Opera Bedae Venerabilis…in octo tomos distincta. vol.1. Basel.
- Holder-Egger, O. 1881. “Series episcoporum et abbatum Germaniae”. Pp. 281–392 in G. Waitz ed. Monumenta Germaniae Historica: Scriptores. vol. 13. Hannover.
- Honigmann, E. 1929. Die sieben Klimata und die ΠΟΛΕΙΣ ΕΠΙΣΗΜΟΙ. Heidelberg.
- Jacquemard, C. 2006. “Erectio, inclinatio/erectus, inclinatus: de Vitruve à Gerbert d’Aurillac (à propos de l’expression de la distance angulaire fin Xe–début XIe siècle)”. Pp. 157–162 in D. Conso, A. Gonzales, and J.-Y. Guillaumin edd. Les vocabulaires techniques des arpenteurs romains. Besançon.
- Jacquemard, C. 2015. “La réinvention de l’astrolabe au Moyen Âge: l’exemple du De statu mundi”. Pp. 191–211 in P. Fleury, C. Jacquemard, and S. Madeleine edd. La technologie gréco-romaine: transmission, restitution et médiation. Caen.
- Jones, C. W. 1977. Bedae Venerabilis opera, pars I. Opera didascalia. vol. 2. Turnhout.
- Jullien, M.-H. 2010. Clavis des auteurs du moyen âge: territoire français 735–987. vol. 3. Turnhout.
- Juste, D. 2007. Les Alchandreana primitifs. Leiden.
- Juste, D. 2016. “Hermann der Lahme und das Astrolab im Spiegel der neuesten Forschung”. Pp. 273–284 in F. Heinzer and T. Zotz edd. Hermann der Lahme. Stuttgart.
- Juste, D. 2021. “MS London, British Library, Arundel 339”. Updated 4 July 2023. Ptolemaeus Arabus et Latinus. Manuscripts. Online http://ptolemaeus.badw.de/ms/47.
- Juste, D. 2022. “MS Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 18927”. Ptolemaeus Arabus et Latinus. Manuscripts. Online http://ptolemaeus.badw.de/ms/87.
- Kunitzsch, P. 1966. Typen von Sternverzeichnissen in astronomischen Handschriften des zehnten bis vierzehnten Jahrhunderts. Wiesbaden.
- Kunitzsch, P. 1981. “On the Authenticity of the Treatise on the Composition and Use of the Astrolabe Ascribed to Messahalla”. Archives internationales d’historie des sciences 31: 42–62. Repr. ch. 10 in P. Kunitzsch. 1989. The Arabs and the Stars. Northampton.
- Kunitzsch, P. 1982. “Glossar der arabischen Fachausdrücke in der mittelalterlichen europäischen Astrolabliteratur”. Nachrichten der Akademie der Wissenschaften in Göttingen, phil.-hist. Kl.11: 455–571.
- Kunitzsch, P. 1987. “Al-Khwārizmī as a Source for the Sententie astrolabii.” Pp. 227–236 in D. A. King and G. Saliba edd. From Deferent to Equant. New York. Repr. ch. 9 in P. Kunitzsch. 1989. The Arabs and the Stars. Northampton.
- Kunitzsch, P. 1994. “On Six Kinds of Astrolabe: A Hitherto Unknown Latin Treatise”. Centaurus 37: 200–208.
- Kunitzsch, P. 1998. “Traces of a Tenth-Century Spanish-Arabic Astrolabe”. Zeitschrift für Geschichte der arabisch-islamischen Wissenschaften 12: 113–120. Repr ch. 16 in P. Kunitzsch. 2004. Stars and Numbers. Hampshire.
- Kunitzsch, P. 1999–2000. “Three Dubious Stars in the Oldest European Table of Astrolabe Stars”. Zeitschrift für Geschichte der arabisch-islamischen Wissenschaften 13: 57–69.
- Kunitzsch, P. 2000a. “A Note on Ascelinus’ Table of Astrolabe Stars”. Annals of Science 57: 181–185.
- Kunitzsch, P. 2000b. “The Chapter on the Stars in an Early European Treatise on the Use of the Astrolabe (ca. AD 1000)”. Suhayl 1: 243–250. Repr. ch. 20 in P. Kunitzsch. 2004. Stars and Numbers. Hampshire.
- Kunitzsch, P. and R. Lorch. 1994. Maslama’s Notes on Ptolemy’s Planisphaerium and Related Texts. Munich.
- Lipton, J. D. 1978. The Rational Evaluation of Astrology in the Period of Arabo-Latin Translation ca. 1126–1187 AD. PhD dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles.
- Lohr, A. 2013. Der Computus Gerlandi. Stuttgart.
- Lorch, R. 1999. “The Treatise on the Astrolabe by Rudolf of Bruges”. Pp. 55–100 in L. Nauta and A. Vanderjagt edd. Between Demonstration and Imagination. Leiden.
- Lorch, R.; G. Brey; S. Kirschner; and C. Schöner. 1994. “Ibn aṣ-Ṣaffārs Traktat über das Astrolab in der Übersetzung von Plato von Tivoli”. Pp. 125–180 in B. Fritscher and G. Brey edd. Cosmographica et geographica. vol. 1. Munich.
- Lucentini, P. and M. D. Delp. 2006. Hermetis Trismegisti De sex rerum principiis. Turnhout.
- Magee, J. 2016. Calcidius: On Plato’s Timaeus. Cambridge, MA.
- Martí, R. and M. Viladrich. 1983. “En torno a los tratados de uso del astrolabio hasta el siglo XIII en al-Andalus, la Marca Hispánica y Castilla”. Pp. 9–74 in J. Vernet ed. Nuevos Estudios sobre astronomía española en el siglo de Alfonso X. Barcelona.
- Materni, M. 2007. “Attività scientifiche di Gerberto d’Aurillac”. Archivum Bobiense 29: 225–317.
- Migne, J.-P. 1854. Patrologia latina. vol. 172. Paris.
- Migne, J.-P. 1862. Patrologia latina. vol. 90. Paris.
- Millás Vallicrosa, J. M. 1931. Assaig d’història de les idees fisiques i matemàtiques a la Catalunya medieval. vol. 1. Barcelona.
- Millás Vallicrosa, J. M. 1940. “Un nuevo tratado de astrolabio de R. Abraham Ibn ʿEzra”. Al-Andalus 5: 1–29.
- Millás Vallicrosa, J. M. 1942. Las traducciones orientales en los manuscritos de la Biblioteca Catedral de Toledo. Madrid.
- Millás Vallicrosa, J. M. 1944. “Sobre un ‘Tratado de astrolabio’ atribuído a R. Abraham Ibn ʿEzra”. Sefarad 4: 31–38.
- Millás Vallicrosa, J. M. 1955. “Los primeros tratados de astrolabio en la España árabe”. Revista del Instituto Egipcio de Estudios Islámicos en Madrid 3: 35–76.
- Möser-Mersky, G. and M. Mihaliuk. 1966. Mittelalterliche Bibliothekskataloge Österreichs. vol. 4. Graz.
- North, J. D. 1976. Richard of Wallingford. 3 vols. Oxford.
- Nothaft, C. P. E. 2014. Medieval Latin Christian Texts on the Jewish Calendar. Leiden.
- Nothaft, C. P. E. 2017. Walcher of Malvern. Turnhout.
- Nothaft, C. P. E. 2019. “An Overlooked Construction Manual for the Quadrans Vetustissimus”. Nuncius 34: 517–534.
- Nothaft, C. P. E. 2023. “A Third Latin Translation of Ibn al-Ṣaffār’s Treatise on the Uses of the Astrolabe”. Mediterranea 8: 71–107.
- Pedersen, F. S. 2002. The Toledan Tables. 4 vols. Copenhagen.
- Poulle, E. 1954. “L’astrolabe médiéval d’après les manuscrits de la Bibliothèque Nationale”. Bibliothèque de l’École des chartes 112: 81–103.
- Poulle, E. 1955. “La fabrication des astrolabes au Moyen Âge”. Techniques et Civilisations 4: 117–128.
- Poulle, E. 1956. “Peut-on dater les astrolabes médiévaux?” Revue d’histoire des sciences et de leurs applications 9: 301–322.
- Poulle, E. 1964. “Le traité d’astrolabe de Raymond de Marseille”. Studi medievali, 3rd ser. 5: 866–900.
- Poulle, E. 1972. “Les instruments astronomiques de l’Occident latin aux XIe et XIIe siècles”. Cahiers de civilisation médiévale 15: 27–40.
- Poulle, E. 1985. “L’astronomie de Gerbert”. Pp. 597–617 in M. Tosi ed. Gerberto: scienza, storia e mito. Bobbio. Repr. ch. 11 in E. Poulle. 1996. Astronomie planétaire au Moyen Âge latin. Hampshire.
- Poulle, E. 1987. “Le traité de l’astrolabe d’Adélard de Bath”. Pp. 119–132 in C. Burnett ed. Adelard of Bath. London.
- Poulle, E. 1995. “La littérature astrolabique latine jusqu’au XIIIe siècle”. Physis 32: 227–237.
- Poulle, E. 1998. “L’astronomie latine au XIIe siècle”. Pp. 75–88 in Cieli e terre nei secoli XI–XII. Milan.
- Poulle, E. 2000. “Astrolabium, astrolapsus, horologium: enquête sur un vocabulaire”. Pp. 437–448 in L. Callebat and O. Desbordes edd. Science antique, science médiévale. Autour d’Avranches 235. Hildesheim.
- Pradel-Baquerre, M.; C. Biasi; and A. Gévaudan. 2016. Pseudo-Bède. De mundi caelestis terrestrisque constitutione liber. Paris.
- Puigvert i Planagumà, G. 2000. Astronomia i astrologia al monestir de Ripoll. Barcelona.
- Rackham, H. 1949. Pliny: Natural History. rev. edn. vol. 1. Cambridge, MA.
- Riché, P. and J.-P. Callu. 1993. Gerbert d’Aurillac. Correspondance. 2 vols. Paris.
- Rodríguez Arribas, J. 2014. “Medieval Jews and Medieval Astrolabes: Where, Why, How, and What For?” Pp. 221–271 in S. Stern and C. Burnett edd. Time, Astronomy, and Calendars in the Jewish Tradition. Leiden.
- Runciman, D. 2019. “Bishop Bartholomew of Exeter (d. 1184) and the Heresy of Astrology”. Journal of Ecclesiastical History 70: 265–282.
- Samsó, J. 1991. “Cultura científica àrab i cultura científica llatina a la Catalunya altmedieval. El monestir de Ripoll i el naixement de la ciència catalana”. Pp. 253–269 in Symposium internacional sobre els orígens de Catalunya (segles VIII–IX). vol. 1. Barcelona.
- Samsó, J. 2000. “Maslama al--Majrīṭī and the Star Table in the Treatise De mensura astrolabii”. Pp. 506–522 in M. Folkerts and R. Lorch edd. Sic Itur ad Astra. Wiesbaden.
- Samsó, J. 2003. “El astrolabio ‘carolingio’ de Marcel Destombes y la introducción del astrolabio en la Catalunya medieval”. Memorias de la Real Academia de Ciencias y Artes de Barcelona 60.10: 345–356.
- Samsó, J. 2004a. “Els inicis de la introducció de la ciència àrab a Europa a través de Catalunya”. Pp. 115–159 in J. Vernet and R. Parés edd. La ciència en la història dels Països Catalans. vol. 1. Valencia.
- Samsó, J. 2004b. “La introducción de la astronomía árabe en Cataluña a fines del siglo X”. Pp. 301–318 in Ante el milenario del reinado de Sancho el Mayor. Pamplona.
- Samsó, J. 2012. “‘Dixit Abraham Iudeus’. Algunas observaciones sobre los textos astronómicos latinos de Abraham Ibn ‘Ezra”. Iberia Judaica 4: 171–200.
- Samsó, J. 2020. On Both Sides of the Strait of Gibraltar. Leiden.
- Schonhardt, M. 2022. Mit Sphaera und Astrolab: “Die Entdeckung der Natur” in südostdeutschen Klöstern im Hohen Mittelalter. Turnhout.
- Schramm, M.; C.-P. A. Schütz; M. Schütz; M. Brunold; and M. Germann. 2006–2007. “Der Astrolabtext aus der Handschrift Codex 196, Burgerbibliothek Bern—Spuren arabischer Wissenschaft im mittelalterlichen Abendland”. Zeitschrift für Geschichte der arabischislamischen Wissenschaften 17: 199–300.
- Sela, S.; C. Steel; C. P. E. Nothaft; D. Juste; and C. Burnett. 2020. “A Newly Discovered Treatise by Abraham Ibn Ezra and Two Treatises Attributed to al-Kindī in a Latin Translation by Henry Bate”. Mediterranea 5: 193–305.
- Suter, H. 1914. Die astronomischen Tafeln des Muḥammed ibn Mūsā al-Khwārizmī in der Bearbeitung des Maslama ibn Aḥmed al-Madjrīṭī und der latein. Übersetzung des Athelhard von Bath. Copenhagen.
- Thomson, R. 2007. “The Place of Germany in the Twelfth-Century Renaissance”. Pp. 19–42 in A. I. Beach ed. Manuscripts and Monastic Culture. Turnhout.
- Thomson, R. B. 2022. Pseudo-Māshā’allāh: On the Astrolabe. Version 1.7. 4 vols. Toronto. Online: https://shareok.org/handle/11244/14221.3.
- Vernet Ginés, J. and J. Samsó. 2004. “El petit renaixement dels comtats catalans de l’època carolíngia”. Pp. 31–43 in J. Vernet and R. Parés edd. La ciència en la història dels Països Catalans. vol. 1. Valencia.
- Victor, S. K. 1979. Practical Geometry in the High Middle Ages. Philadelphia.
- Viladrich, M. 2009. “La transmission des idées scientifiques et astrologiques d’origine arabe dans la Marca Hispanica au temps de l’abbé Oliba: vieilles idées et questions nouvelles”. Le Cahiers de Saint-Michel de Cuxa 40: 1–11.
- Viladrich, M. and R. Martí. 1981. “En torno a los tratados hispánicos sobre construcción de astrolabio hasta el siglo XIII”. Pp. 79–99 in J. Vernet ed. Textos y estudios sobre astronomía española en el siglo XIII. Barcelona.
- Viré, G. 1992. Hygini de astronomia. Stuttgart.
- Wiesenbach, J. 1991. “Wilhelm von Hirsau: Astrolab und Astronomie im 11. Jahrhundert”. Pp. 109–156 in K. Schreiner ed. Hirsau: St. Peter und Paul 1091–1991. vol. 2. Stuttgart.
- Wiesenbach, J. 1996. “Wilhelm von Hirsau und die Sphaera: Zum sogenannten Astrolabium von St. Emmeram”. Pp. 108–114 in Romanik in Regensburg. Regensburg.
- Willis, J. 1970. Ambrosii Theodosii Macrobii commentarii in somnium Scipionis. Stuttgart. Repr. 1994.
- Willis, J. 1983. Martianus Capella. Leipzig.
- Zinner, E. 1925. Verzeichnis der astronomischen Handschriften des deutschen Kulturgebietes. Munich.
- Zuccato, M. 2010. “Gerbert of Aurillac and the Astrolabe: An Open Historical Problem”. Pp. 114–123 in C. Sigismondi ed. Orbe Novus. Rome.
- Zuccato, M. 2014. “Arabic Singing Girls, the Pope, and the Astrolabe: Arabic Science in Tenth-Century Latin Europe”. Viator 45: 99–120.