The objective of this research was to measure the effect of P. penetrans densities on the vegetative growth of three apple dwarfing rootstocks Bud 9, M.9 and M.26 under field microplot conditions. Under 500 nematodes kg-1 soil density, the shoot dry weights of Bud 9, M.9 and M.26 rootstocks were significantly reduced by 30%, 23% and 14% respectively. Under the 1 500 nematodes kg-1 soil density, the dry shoot weight of Bud 9 and M.9 were not significantly different from the 500 nematodes kg-1 soil density except M.26 which exhibited a 29% decrease. The root dry weights of rootstocks were not significantly reduced when exposed to these P. penetrans densities except M.26 which was reduced 26% relative to non-inoculated trees under the 1 500 nematodes kg-1 soil density. These results confirm the pathogenic effect of P. penetrans on dwarfing apple rootstocks. Although preliminary, these results suggest some tolerance of M.26 to P. penetrans under lower density when compared to M.9 and Bud 9. Under higher nematode densities, both Bud 9 and M.9 exhibited a tolerance of their root system in comparison to M.26. Our results also emphasize the need to further assess the susceptibility/tolerance of dwarfing apple rootstocks to various densities of P. penetrans.
- Pratylenchus penetrans,
- apple rootstock,
- nematode density
L’objectif de cette recherche était de mesurer l’effet des densités de P. penetrans sur la croissance végétative de trois porte-greffes nains, Bud 9, M.9 et M.26 dans des conditions de microparcelle au champ. Soumis à une densité initiale de 500 nématodes kg-1 de sol, les poids secs de nouvelles pousses des porte-greffes Bud 9, M.9 et M.26 ont été réduits de manière significative respectivement de 30 %, 23 % et 14 %. Soumis à une densité initiale de 1 500nématodes kg-1 de sol, les poids secs de Bud 9 et M.9 n’étaient pas significativement différents de ceux exposés à 500 nématodes kg-1 de sol, à l’exception de M.26 qui affichait une diminution de 29 %. Le poids sec des racines des porte-greffes n’a pas été réduit de manière significative lorsqu’ils ont été exposés à ces densités de P. penetrans, à l’exception de M.26, qui a été réduit de 26 % lorsqu’exposé à la densité de 1 500 nématodes kg-1 de sol. Ces résultats confirment l’effet pathogène de P. penetrans sur les porte-greffes nains. Ces résultats préliminaires suggèrent une tolérance de M.26 à P. penetrans sous la densité de 500 nématodes kg-1 de sol. Sous la densité de 1 500 nématodes kg-1 de sol, les Bud 9 et M.9 présentaient tous deux une tolérance de leur système racinaire comparativement à M.26. Ces résultats soulignent également l’importance de poursuivre l’évaluation de la sensibilité/tolérance des porte-greffes nains aux diverses densités du P. penetrans.
- Pratylenchus penetrans,
- porte-greffe du pommier,
- densité de nématode
Corps de l’article
The root-lesion nematode (RLN) Pratylenchus penetrans is the dominant species parasitizing apple trees in eastern North America (Mai et al. 1970; Pitcher et al. 1960; Traquair 1984; Vrain and Rousselle 1980). This species is highly pathogenic to apple seedlings and associated with apple replant disease (Jaffee et al. 1982; Jaffee and Mai 1979). Parker and Mai (1974) reported that the level of damage varied among rootstocks. Currently, the standard practice of apple growers is to replant old sites with dwarf and semi-draft rootstocks immediately after pulling out the old orchards. Rootstocks have the advantage of being very precocious, with high yield efficiency (Webster 1993). This allows growers to change cultivars as necessary without extended periods of lost production. In Eastern Canada, winter hardiness is a primary criterion for the selection of dwarfing rootstocks. Because dwarfing rootstocks have a limited root volume and benefit from supplemental irrigation in dry seasons and in droughty soils, their susceptibility to RLN is suspected to vary with the soil densities at planting. In Quebec, RLN population densities at planting are highly variable but can reach several thousand per kg of soil (Vrain and Rousselle 1980). The main objective of this study was to measure the effect of RLN densities on vegetative growth of three apple dwarfing rootstocks under field microplot conditions.
The impact of three initial population densities of RLN on the vegetative growth of three apple rootstocks under field microplot conditions was studied at the experimental farm of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada at L’Acadie, QC. Field microplots consisted of bottomless wood frames (1 m wide x 2 m long x 0.2 m deep) buried in a loamy sand soil (82% sand, 10% silt, and 8% clay). Microplots were infested in 1998-1999 with a local isolate of P. penetrans from soil from Lavaltrie, QC and rye (Secale cereale) was grown for three consecutive years inside these same microplots to increase P. penetrans densities. No soil fumigation was performed prior to the initial inoculation. Eight control microplots (without nematode) were not infested and planted with marigold (Tageteserecta) cv. Crackerjack to maintain low RLN soil densities.
The growth of three dwarfing apple rootstocks; Bud 9 (Budagovsky 9), M.9 (Malling 9) and M.26 (Malling 26) was evaluated under three initial nematode population density classes: no nematodes, medium (approx. 500 nematodes kg-1 soil), and high (approx. 1 500 nematodes kg-1 soil). Based on counts of RLN kg-1 soil in fall of 2005, eight microplots were allocated to each of the three classes of initial nematode population densities. Actual means and ranges (min-max) for the medium and high population densities were 490 RLN kg-1 (450-540) and 1 470 RLN kg-1 (1390-1620), res-pectively. Prior to planting, the soil was prepared with a motorized cultivator after adding in each microplot 0N-46P-0K fertilizer at 130 g (650 kg ha-1) and 0N-0P-22K (Sul-Po-Mag) at 100 g (500 kg ha-1). Each microplot was divided into three equal submicroplots of 1 m wide x 67 cm long and one of the three genotypes was randomly allocated to each of submicroplots. Each apple rootstock was planted on two 1-m rows (three per row) (15-cm between plants and between rows).
Apple rootstocks (shoot diameter between 7 mm to 10 mm) were purchased from the Boerboom Nursery Inc., St-Paul-D’Abbotsford, QC. Before planting, all plants were cut to 30 cm total length and roots were immerged for four hours in fertilizer solution 10N-52P-10K (5 g L-1). Holes of 15 cm deep and 5 cm diameter were dug. One rootstock was put in each hole and then filled with 500 ml of PRO-MIX BX from Premier Tech, Rivière-du-Loup, QC. (a general purpose peat-based growing medium with vermiculite and perlite) mixed with 10N-52P-10K fertilizer (216 L of Pro-mix mixed with 36 L of 10N-52P-10K [5 g L-1]). All apple rootstocks were planted on 20 April 2006 and were watered after planting. All microplots were fertilized on 4 May with 3.5 L of 10N-52P-10K fertilizer (5 g L-1) and on 23 May with 4 L of 20N-20P-20K (1 g L-1). Weeds were controlled by hand weeding several times during the season.
On 3 October 2006, the shoot and the root of all root-stocks were harvested. The shoots were chopped in 5-cm pieces, oven-dried (70°C) for two days and weighed to record the average shoot weight per rootstock-nematode treatment. The root system of three randomly selected plants per experimental unit was washed under running tap water, oven-dried (70°C) for two days, and weighed to determine the average root weight per rootstock-nematode treatment. Soil samples from each submicroplot were collected to determine the number of RLN before planting on 24 May and at harvest on 3 October 2006. Four soil cores (5 cm x 20 cm) per submicroplot (apple rootstock) were composited into one sample representing the submicroplot. Nematodes were extracted from a 50-cm3 subsample from each composite sample by the modified Baermann pan method (Townshend 1963). Nematodes were counted using a stereo-microscope and expressed as numbers per kg of soil.
The shoot dry weights of Bud 9, M.9 and M.26 rootstocks were significantly reduced under the medium initial population density by 30%, 23% and 14% respectively (ANOVA, p ≤ 0.05) (Table 1). Under the high initial population density, the shoot dry weights of Bud 9 and M.9 were not significantly different from the medium initial population density except M.26 which exhibited a 29% decrease between the medium and high initial population densities (ANOVA, p ≤ 0.05). The root dry weights of rootstocks were not significantly reduced when exposed to either initial population densities except M.26 which was reduced 26% relative to non-inoculated trees at the high density (ANOVA, p ≤ 0.05). In May and October 2006, RLN densities were significantly different from the control (ANOVA, p ≤ 0.05).
These results confirm the pathogenic effect of RLN on dwarfing apple rootstocks under field microplot conditions. But we need to acknowledge the fact that growth of marigold could have had other effects besides keeping RLN densities low (e.g. other root pathogens, beneficial rhizosphere organisms, nutrient availability, etc.). Based on previous experiments performed in these same microplots over the years, our database does not support this hypothesis.
Although preliminary, these results suggest some tolerance of M.26 to RLN under lower density when compared to M.9 and Bud 9. Under higher nematode densities, both Bud 9 and M.9 exhibited a tolerance of their root system in comparison to M.26. Now, it has been previously demonstrated that the pathogenicity of RLN on apple will be affected by seeding age (Jaffe and Mai 1979). Because the root-lesion nematode feeds on the small rootlets and thus decreases the normal uptake of water and nutrients, the growth of dwarfing rootstocks could be more inclined to be affected during the establishment years. Thus, it would be safer to provide adequate moisture during this critical period. Our results emphasize the need to further assess the susceptibility/ tolerance of dwarfing apple rootstocks to various RLN popu-lation densities.
- Jaffee, B.A., G.S. Abawi, and W.F. Mai. 1982. Role of soil microflora and Pratylenchus penetrans in an apple replant disease. Phytopathology 72 : 247-251.
- Jaffee, B.A., and W.F. Mai. 1979. Growth of apple seedlings by Pratylenchuspenetrans as influenced by seedling age at inoculation. J. Nematol. 11 : 161-165.
- Mai, W.F., K.G. Parker, and K.D. Hickey. 1970. Populations of Pratylenchuspenetrans and growth of apple in response to soil treatment with nematicides. Plant Dis. Rep. 54 : 792-795.
- Pitcher, R.S., Z.A. Patrick, and W.B. Mountain. 1960. Studies on the host-parasite relations of Pratylenchus penetrans (Cobb) to apple seedlings I. Pathogenicity under sterile conditions. Nematologica 5 : 309-314.
- Townshend, J.L. 1963. A modification and evaluation of the apparatus for the Oostenbrink direct cotton-wool filter extraction method. Nematologica 9 : 106-110.
- Vrain, T.C., and G.L. Rousselle. 1980. Distribution of plant-parasitic nematodes in Quebec apple orchards. Plant Dis. 64 : 582-583.
- Parker, K.G., and W.F. Mai, 1974. Damage caused by Pratylenchus penetrans to apple trees in the orchard growing on different rootstocks. Plant Dis. Rep. 58 : 1007-1011.
- Traquair, J.A. 1984. Etiology and control of orchard replant problems: a review. Can. J. Plant Pathol. 6 : 54-62.
- Webster, A.D. 1993. New dwarfing rootstocks for apple, pear plum and sweet cherry - a brief review. Acta Hortic. 349 : 145-153.